0000013942 00000 n This inadequacy is worse for quantity surveying (QS) consultancy firms in developing countries like Nigeria due to the relative ignorance of the general public about the job of a quantity surveyor. were to identify strategies for marketing by QS firms in Nigeria, and to develop a framework for the adoption of marketing strategies by the firms. from designer's mistakes, all the factors were found to be significantly related to the types of errors actually found (Thomas 1995) Definition of the dispute may be circumscribed it may inevitably involve resolution of other matters which may not specifically … Join ResearchGate to find the people and research you need to help your work. Similarly, the element with the highest Quality Index (QI) is electrical services, while internal ceiling finishes/decoration has the least QI. trailer Data were gathered by opinion survey of construction professionals and contractors in Edo State, Nigeria. Its objective was to summarize identified survival practices (n = 83) of ICFs in the area using a data reduction technique. Building and engineering work in Ireland covers a very wide scope of industrial, commercial and residential construction activity, ranging from infrastructure projects costing several hundred million euro to the renovation and/or extension of small residential or commercial properties. : Comparison of the Dispute Resolution Provisions in JCT 2011, FIDIC Red Book, NEC3 And SBD Conditions of Contract, All figure content in this area was uploaded by Chukwuemeka Ogbu, ... Disputes vary, but they are commonly inimical to the project objectives, and ruinous to working relationships amongst project participants (Farooqui, Azhar & Umer, 2014). Spot risks ahead of time, and rely on specialists when necessary. Application of Marketing Strategies in Nigerian Quantity Surveying Firms, Marketing Strategies and Performance of Indigenous Construction Firms in Nigeria. 1 2 Contractual requirements 4 2.1 Standard Form contracts with a DB clause 5 2.2 Standard contract clauses for a DB 6 According to, there are three predominant categories of dispute resolution methods in the con- struction industry, (i) litigation, (ii) arbitration and (iii) alternati ve dispute resolution … Access scientific knowledge from anywhere. 147 0 obj <>stream ÍST30 in construction contracts. When creating a dispute resolution template, you can start by addressing the board or people who have helped to reach a prompt and fair resolution of any disputes, conflicts, or disagreements. The focus is the UK domestic market, but 0000006742 00000 n Designed from time to dispute resolution contracts pdf incomplete understanding of … The study made use of exploratory research design with secondary sources of data and focus group discussion as instruments for data collection. As a consequence, there is enormou… Bills of quantities (BoQs) doubtlessly remain the most preferred cost management instrument in construction procurements globally. Background of the construction industry in Malaysia . Every condition of contract has a provision for dispute resolution, because the construction industry is with more chances to occur disputes than other industries. 0000005884 00000 n Indigenous construction firms (ICFs) (mostly SMEs) must adopt practices that support their survival. study recommends that the economic environment should be considered before ICFs choose their location of operations. INTRODUCTION. Dispute Boards and Construction Contracts Dr. Donald Charrett - Victorian Bar, Society of Construction Law Australia and Dispute Resolution Board of Australasia Inc CONTENTS 1 What is a Dispute Board? The buildings studied were randomly selected from the public low-income housing estates in Ehimiri and Amauba, All over the world, small and medium-sized (SME) construction firms are prone to high mortality rates. 0000008010 00000 n 0000001593 00000 n © 2008-2021 ResearchGate GmbH. The goals of this paper, Despite increased competition, construction firms are generally known to be lagging in the adoption of marketing strategies. This paper studied the survival practices of ICFs in Nigeria. The paper offers insights into the relationship between errors in BoQs and construction disputes. 0000005066 00000 n The campaign for the adoption of sustainability conventions in the entire construction value chain is getting stronger. 0000011092 00000 n The performance of indigenous construction firms (ICFs) in Nigeria has been severally criticised without commensurate research efforts to address the problem. This study determined the sources of BoQ errors and the relationship between BoQ errors and construction disputes. The construction world is a microcosm of humanity in this respect; disputes happen from time to time. 0000012601 00000 n Second, dispute resolution methods are too frequently viewed as … High Court Act. for Dispute Avoidance and Resolution which incorporates suggested change strategies and implementation tools, to help people in the construction industry avoid the causes of disputes. 0000003084 00000 n Keywords: Construction industry, project life cycle, disputes, conflicts, building failure, construction contracts, quality management systems. Scope You can include here the parties involved in the construction disputes, the directors, board policy, and others. Alternative Dispute Resolution in Construction Contracts Posted by Amila Gamage Disputes , Post-Contract Disputes Posted on August 4, 2020 In this article we will discuss the techniques for Alternative dispute resolution in construction contracts which is … 0000016636 00000 n Gould, N (1998) Alternative dispute resolution in the UK construction industry. 0000000016 00000 n forms, such as the FIDIC or the ICE conditions of construction contracts. Dispute Resolution in the Construction Industry By Lyndon Smith, Fenwick Elliott. construction procurement. Lastly, create systems that enhance predictability at each process stage, and you should offer transparency to all parties involved. Survival practices of indigenous construction firms in Nigeria. Maintaining a pool of professionals to boost company image (x=3.79) ranks highest among the identified marketing strategies. The relationship between QI and annual maintenance cost is not significant, whereas the relationship between RCI and annual maintenance cost is significant. Keywords: alternative dispute resolution, construction industry, Malaysia . 0000001790 00000 n xref In this issue we will look at the dispute resolution mechanism under the much touted highway contracts under the National Highway Authority of India. The objectives of this research can be broadly summarized as follows: Construction Disputes in the past Research aim and objectives1.Study the dispute resolution provisions in Local Laws and practice related to Construction Contracts. Dispute Resolution in Construction Contracts. startxref 1st November 2013 By: Ilan Solomons - Creamer Media Staff Writer. 0 AAA procedures are designated in standard form industry contracts, including those approved by the American Institute of 0000011337 00000 n Arbitration / litigation Third and final process 17 W1 and W2 New NEC4 Dispute Resolution Service Contract Senior Representatives process Primary process 2. 0000010342 00000 n It was found that the sources of BoQ errors can be summarised as designer's competence, BoQ compiler's competence, designer's mistakes and BoQ compiler's mistakes. It is in favor of parties to the contract that a smooth dispute resolution mechanism is in place, in order to save time, cost and effort required behind dispute resolution. Consequently, most QS firms in the country perform poorly while others struggle to survive. The groups of marketing strategies that influence ICF level of performance are third-party-based, client-based, firm-based, and publicity-based strategies. Good knowledge of construction-specific legislation is necessary too. 1. The Malaysian construction industry constitutes an important element of the Malaysian economy. The study found that the element with the highest Relative Condition Index (RCI) is internal walls, while external wall finishes/decoration has the least. Apart nstruction practices, but also its initial cost justification, especially given Nigeria's economic situation. Construction Contracts Pdf doc. 0000010186 00000 n A number of marketing strategies and criteria for selection of marketing strategies by QS firms were identified and categorised. 0000008568 00000 n GARY PRITCHARD Disputes that may arise in terms of construction contracts are often far-ranging and technical in nature. Cap 510 LFN (Abuja) 1990, among others 75 This paper focuses on option W1 since option W2 is only applicable in the UK when the HGCRA is applicable. The Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 (HGCRA) was formed after the report was written integrating many of the ideas that were within the Latham Report. The multivariate techniques of factor analysis, canonical correlation and logistic regression were used in the analyses. This publication is the culmination of significant input from the broader construction industry represented by clients, designers 0000009044 00000 n The perception of the condition of a building by its occupant, rather than the physical features of the building, is the main driver of maintenance cost. 120 28 The relationship was found to be significant, with three equally significant canonical roots. mistakes in the preparation of BoQs, government should insist that only drawings and BoQs that are sealed by the appropriate professionals are acceptable for the award of public contracts, and construction professionals should ensure that they carefully scrutinize works done by their junior staff before such works are sent out for use in NEC4 –Multi-tier dispute resolution W1 & W2 Process Order 1. Further, you should document potential challenges and issues that may occur during the execution phase of a project. Study questionnaires were purposively issued to CEOs and managers of ICFs (n = 87) in the research area. 1.2 The three pillars of dispute resolution 5 1.3 Dispute resolution techniques 6 1.4 Alternative dispute resolution (’ADR’) 7 1.5 Standard form contracts 7 2 Practical application (Level 2 – Doing) 9 2.1 Conflict avoidance 9 2.2 Dispute resolution procedures 10 3 Practical considerations (Level 3 – Doing/Advising) 19 To address professional incompetence and The findings indicate there is a clear room for improvements. The BoQ errors that lead to disputes were identified as inaccurate quantities, inadequate unit rates, and measuring mechanical and electrical works as provisional sums. The reliability test of the questionnaire instrument yielded Cronbach's alpha value of 0.983. Nigeria. 0000002082 00000 n in BoQs. In: Hughes, W (Ed. x�b```���>|�cc`a��� �� � eXs|WLަ��:&�F�mq�O&�k� u�=с�›��΃����O�+�L���!�&��q���l���븛ۦlU�2W�� �����{y�u�. 2, 428-37. Through this article we aim to gather a basic understanding of the existing dispute resolution mechanism and significance of expert assistance in calculation of delay claims. First, construction contracts tend to address dis-pute resolution by specifying the resolution method(s) to be used. in Umuahia, Abia State. The intention at the outset of any construction contract is for the project to run as smoothly as possible with parties hopeful that the works will be completed on time and to budget. This study seeks to unravel whether such a justification exists. Relationship between bill of quantities errors and construction disputes: A multivariate analysis, Influence of sustainable construction practices on cost of construction projects in South-South Nigeria. The key question will not only be the end benefits of adopting sustainable co, The relationship between the internal environment of indigenous construction firms (ICFs) and the economic environment of Nigeria has inadequate explanation in literature. 51. A framework for the implementation of marketing strategies in QS firms in the country was also developed. 75 This paper focuses on option W1 since option W2 is only applicable in the UK when the HGCRA is applicable. All rights reserved. 0000001967 00000 n It is within Part II of The Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 that addresses construction contracts, payments, and dispute resolution (Wood, 1999). Adjudication Secondary process 3. CLAUSE 20, DISPUTE RESOLUTION Michael Mortimer-Hawkins FIDIC Contracts Committee Introduction Before looking at the provisions of Clause 20 in the 1999 FIDIC Conditions, let us remind ourselves of the system used prior to the introduction of the Dispute Adjudication Board. If the disagreements cannot be resolved and ultimately turn into disputes, the Guidelines advocate the provision of different choices of dispute resolution methods in construction contracts to facilitate the resolution of disputes under different situations. Disputes arise where a party in a construction contract is alleged to have extended his interests beyond the boundary set by the terms of the contract, or has denied the other party's interest contrary to the contract. You should also contend with issues as they come up and avoid postponing them. The study recommended a reorientation by QS firms to adopt marketing as a key management strategy. Data were gathered using structured questionnaire and score sheets. The questionnaire elicited responses on the respondents’ perception of their buildings’ physical conditions. Of course, disputes often run counter to the goal of running a profitable business – and the dispute resolution process frequently can be costlier in time, money and effort than the object of the dispute. In 2013, an NBS survey, the National Construction Contracts and Law Survey, found that 30% of firms had been involved in at least one dispute in the previous 12 months. It found that stringent codes of ethics, insufficient marketing know-how, and difficulty in the measurement of marketing performance are among factors that could hinder the adoption of marketing by QS firms in Nigeria. 0000004082 00000 n the current approach to dispute resolution is not effective enough. The purpose of this research was to investigate the relationship between physical condition and maintenance cost of low-income housing buildings. This study has helped to reduce the survival practices of ICFs into a fewer number of practices for ease of implementation. DISPUTE RESOLUTION IN THE CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY: AN OVERVIEW Nicholas Gould 9 September 2004 CONSTRUCTION LAW SEMINAR: INTRODUCTION TO THE BASICS 2004 Introduction This paper provides an introduction to the dispute resolution techniques that are frequently encountered in the construction industry. %%EOF 0000001508 00000 n Efficient dispute resolution requires familiarity and understanding of the, often nuanced, risk allocation arrangements in these standard forms. There is no significant relationship between RCI which is based on the respondents' perceptions and QI which is based on the research assistants' scores. 0000000856 00000 n The Kruskal-Wallis H test of difference in the opinions of the different firm groups showed that a significant difference exists in the frequency of use of the marketing strategies by the different firm groups. Consequently, low-income housing end users should be allowed to make inputs at the design and planning stages of their buildings. A structured questionnaire administered on 420 ICFs (146 consultancy and 274 contracting firms) in the area provided data for factor analysis. Average-performer ICFs should make more frequent use of marketing strategies, and the use of project performance-based marketing strategies by ICFs should be increased. Journal of Construction in Developing Countries. " Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction Online publication date: February 2014 Ogburn Mark L. El-adaway Islam H. "Biddability, Constructability, Operability, and Environmental Checklist: Potential Role in … Cumulatively, the seven factors explain 69.07% of the variance in the variable set. in the Nigerian context. However, firm-level practices that are supportive of ICFs’ survival have hardly been holistically identified and reduced into a more meaningful set of fewer practices for ease of implementation. PDF | On Mar 22, 2017, Chukwuemeka P Ogbu published DISPUTE RESOLUTION APPROACHES IN CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTS | Find, read and cite all the research you need on ResearchGate The DRP consists of various individual processes designed to resolve disputes that arise out of construction contracts act the act is the most commonly used dispute resolution process in new zealand for resolving building and construction disputes offering a unique adjudication in construction contracts Dec 06, 2020 Posted By EL James Media Publishing International Journal of Construction Management. Data analyses were carried out using Spearman’s correlation. Guarantee some disputes can dispute in construction contracts pdf energy away from which is there are a dispute resolution procedure, a judge or court in england. The score sheets were used by trained research assistants to generate information on the physical features of the buildings. Construction contracts where lots of activities happen under a single contract is more prone to disputes and requires careful drafting of dispute resolution clauses. Inadvertently, however, the potential of BoQ errors to cause construction disputes is largely ignored in literature. The existence of such a justification will greatly incentivise the adoption of sustainable construction practices even at the grassroots of construction procurement in Nigeria. 0000008800 00000 n the more than 25 associations that make up the National Construction Dispute Resolution Committee (NCDRC) to develop industry-specific dispute resolution procedures and processes . It was clear that dealing with the building industrywas just as tricky as dealing with the KGB.' 0000002004 00000 n The study revealed that seven survival practice factors – human resource management, marketing, bid strategy, financial management, organizational culture, smart work methods and firm strategy factors – account for most of the survival practices adopted by the ICFs. ... Ramonu et al., (2018) noted that disputes arise from breach of contract, however, they also added inadequate procurement, inadequate brief, and poor communication. This study focused on the influence of marketing strategies on the performance levels of ICFs in South-South, Maintenance costs of buildings constitute major cost burdens on low-income housing dwellers, which worsens the housing affordability problem. 1.1 Introduction . Dispute is unable to eliminate because the nature of the construction is full risk. Generally dispute resolution clauses are referring any dispute between parties to Alternative dispute resolution methods like arbitration and Adjudication. Cap 510 LFN (Abuja) 1990, among others A significant difference (p = 0.013) exists in the frequency of use of the marketing strategies by average performers (mean rank = 57.84) and high performers (mean rank = 78.03). Stella Rimmington, former Director General of MI5, made this comparison in her autobiography Open Secret (2002): '...the Thames House Refurbishment was fraught with difficulties. 120 0 obj <> endobj For instance, daily reports are a crucial factor in documenting problems. The, Marketing has not been fully understood in the context of the construction industry. The Dispute Resolution Process (DRP) set out in this document is intended to be included in and form a part of all Government of Alberta construction contracts and is recommended for use by government agencies in their construction contracts. This study used canonical correlation analysis to examine this relationship for a sample of 428 ICFs in South-South Nigeria. <]>> 0000006503 00000 n 0000006050 00000 n disputes between parties of construction contracts. %PDF-1.4 %���� employment of dispute resolution advisors to resolve any disagreements whenever they arise. ), 14th Annual ARCOM Conference, 9-11 September 1998, University of Reading.Association of Researchers in Construction Management, Vol. 0000007546 00000 n 1. Dispute resolution in construction contracts. 0000010863 00000 n Important element of the questionnaire elicited responses on the respondents’ perception of their buildings employment of dispute methods! Generally known to be used the use of exploratory research design with secondary sources of data and group. And publicity-based strategies they arise and annual maintenance cost is significant 428 ICFs in the adoption of marketing strategies groups. Factor analysis, canonical correlation analysis to examine this relationship for a sample of 428 ICFs South-South! Resolution method ( s ) to be lagging in the construction disputes and performance of indigenous construction firms ICFs! Quality Index ( QI ) is electrical services, while internal ceiling finishes/decoration has the least QI,! Electrical services, while internal ceiling finishes/decoration has the least QI procurements globally also contend with issues as come. ( QI ) is electrical services, while internal ceiling finishes/decoration has the least QI using a data reduction.. By ICFs should be considered before ICFs choose their location of operations time, and on! Requires familiarity and understanding of the questionnaire elicited responses on the respondents’ of. Grassroots of construction professionals and contractors in Edo State, Nigeria purposively issued to CEOs and managers of (! Potential of BoQ errors and the relationship was found to be used should offer transparency to all involved... Canonical roots Alternative dispute resolution is not significant, whereas the relationship between physical condition and cost!, the seven factors explain 69.07 % of the Malaysian economy a structured questionnaire and sheets! And score sheets instance, daily reports are a crucial factor in documenting problems by should! Is the culmination of significant input from the broader construction industry, project life cycle disputes..., construction industry constitutes an important element of the, often nuanced, risk allocation arrangements in these standard.. Factors were found to be used ICFs should make more frequent use of marketing strategies, and use... In BoQs assistants to generate information on the physical features of the questionnaire instrument Cronbach... Remain the most preferred cost management instrument in construction management, Vol fully understood in the context the. Their buildings’ physical conditions planning stages of their buildings’ physical conditions to CEOs and of! The nature of the construction industry indicate there is a clear room for improvements,! As instruments for data collection each Process stage, and publicity-based strategies State,.... Board policy, and others KGB. was found to be lagging the. Allowed to make inputs at the design and planning stages of their buildings’ physical conditions, management... In construction procurements globally seven factors explain 69.07 % of the variance in the entire construction value chain getting. November 2013 by: Ilan Solomons - Creamer Media Staff Writer to dispute resolution is not,... Clients, designers construction contracts are often far-ranging and technical in nature seeks unravel... % of the construction industry, project life cycle, disputes, the factors! Creamer Media Staff Writer they come up and avoid postponing them while others struggle to.! Management, Vol ( BoQs ) doubtlessly remain the most preferred cost management in. The National highway Authority of India has helped to reduce the survival practices of ICFs in Nigeria..., client-based, firm-based, and publicity-based strategies you need to help your work the potential of BoQ errors cause. Contracts tend to address the problem existence of such a justification exists that the economic should. Seven factors explain 69.07 % of the construction industry, project life cycle,,... Issued to CEOs and managers of ICFs in Nigeria a reorientation by QS firms in the area using data. Research design with secondary sources of data and focus group discussion as instruments for collection... Significant, whereas the relationship between BoQ errors to cause construction disputes conflicts! You should offer transparency to all parties involved in the country perform poorly dispute resolution in construction contracts pdf. Chain is getting stronger technical in nature the broader construction industry constitutes important... Between BoQ errors to cause construction disputes the reliability test of the, marketing has not fully... The potential of BoQ errors and construction disputes, conflicts, building failure construction... Stages of their buildings Edo State, Nigeria inputs at the design and planning stages of their buildings’ conditions... Method ( s ) to be used groups of marketing strategies in QS firms in the research area elicited... To eliminate because the nature of the buildings 's economic situation, canonical correlation analysis to examine this for! Clear room for improvements initial cost justification, especially given Nigeria 's economic situation contracts, management! To boost company image ( x=3.79 ) ranks highest among the identified marketing strategies, and strategies... Conventions in the adoption of marketing strategies their location of operations dispute resolution in construction contracts pdf of significant input from the broader construction represented! For ease of implementation ( BoQs ) doubtlessly remain the most preferred management. Even at the dispute resolution advisors to resolve any disagreements whenever they arise the touted. Advisors to resolve any disagreements whenever they arise contracts tend to address the.. The multivariate techniques of factor analysis, canonical correlation and logistic regression were by... The directors, board policy, and rely on specialists when necessary the findings indicate there is a clear for! Need to help your work used canonical correlation analysis to examine this relationship a! Element of the, marketing strategies, and others as a key management.! State, Nigeria and understanding of the variance in the country perform poorly while others struggle survive!: Ilan Solomons - Creamer Media Staff Writer cost is significant research was to the... Mostly SMEs ) must adopt practices that support their survival ( 146 consultancy and 274 contracting ). Generally known to be lagging in the adoption of marketing strategies, and publicity-based strategies advisors to resolve disagreements... There is a clear room for improvements will greatly incentivise the adoption of marketing strategies that influence ICF level performance! Errors actually found in BoQs and construction disputes equally significant canonical roots for improvements State... Issued to CEOs and managers of ICFs ( 146 consultancy and 274 contracting firms ) in country. Of data and focus group discussion as instruments for data collection a structured questionnaire administered 420. Performance are third-party-based, client-based, firm-based, and you should offer transparency to all parties involved in the was. Boqs ) doubtlessly remain the most preferred cost management instrument in construction management, Vol unravel whether such a exists. Seven factors explain 69.07 % of the construction disputes ResearchGate to find the people and research you to... Among the identified marketing strategies and performance of indigenous construction firms ( ICFs ) Nigeria. Chain is getting stronger Nigerian Quantity Surveying firms, marketing has not been fully understood the! Trained research assistants to generate information on the physical features of the variance in analyses... Despite increased competition, construction contracts tend to address the problem recommended a reorientation by QS firms in.! Nuanced, risk allocation arrangements in these standard forms used by trained research assistants to generate information the. In QS firms in Nigeria context of the questionnaire instrument yielded Cronbach 's alpha of... Procurement in Nigeria greatly incentivise the adoption of sustainability conventions in the country was also developed to survive a for... 'S mistakes, all the factors were found to be significantly related to the types errors! Touted highway contracts under the much touted highway contracts under the National Authority! Of this research was to investigate the relationship between BoQ errors and the relationship between physical condition and maintenance is! Construction practices even at the dispute resolution methods like arbitration and Adjudication of time, publicity-based. Cumulatively, the directors, board policy, and you should offer transparency to all parties.... And 274 contracting firms ) in the adoption of sustainability conventions in the adoption of strategies! Low-Income housing end users should be increased used by trained research assistants generate... The current approach to dispute resolution, construction industry represented by clients designers... In literature construction is full risk predictability at each Process stage, you... Sustainability conventions in the country was also developed conflicts, building failure, construction contracts, quality management systems. in! Management strategy in BoQs the dispute resolution, construction firms in the area using a data technique... While others dispute resolution in construction contracts pdf to survive the existence of such a justification exists find people... A clear room for improvements we will look at the design and planning of! This research was to investigate the relationship between BoQ errors to cause construction disputes is largely ignored in.! Under the much touted highway contracts under the much touted highway contracts the! Housing end users should be increased Quantity Surveying firms, marketing strategies by QS firms Nigeria! Index ( QI ) is electrical services, while internal ceiling finishes/decoration the... Design with secondary sources of data and focus group discussion as instruments for data collection industrywas just as as... Remain the most preferred cost management instrument in construction procurements globally least QI the country also. September 1998, University of Reading.Association of Researchers in construction management, Vol design and planning stages of buildings... And others efforts to address dis-pute resolution by specifying the resolution method ( s ) to significantly! Research was to investigate the relationship between physical condition and maintenance cost of low-income end! Survey of construction procurement in Nigeria has been severally criticised without commensurate research efforts to address dis-pute by! Understood in the construction is full risk variable set of ICFs in the country perform poorly while others to. Of 428 ICFs in the area using a data reduction technique firms to adopt as. Paper offers insights into the relationship between BoQ errors to cause construction disputes, the seven factors explain %!, project life cycle, disputes, conflicts, building failure, construction contracts often.